Sign up to stay up to date on the Bay Shore Home Values!

or Create your own market report
Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
99 Newbrook Lane Unit #101 1 1 810 $250,000 $308 1 day
30 Hemlock Lane 4 2 N/A $649,999 Unknown 0 days
980 Gardiner Drive 7 3 N/A $799,999 Unknown 0 days
980 Candlewood Road 3 2 N/A $494,999 Unknown 4 days
1359 Saint Louis Avenue 4 2 N/A $525,000 Unknown 5 days
19 Joseph Street 5 2 N/A $410,000 Unknown 6 days
6 Atlantic Street 3 2 N/A $489,990 Unknown 6 days
23 Daniels Way Unit #23 3 4 2,800 $849,000 $303 8 days
267 3rd Avenue 4 2 N/A $599,000 Unknown 8 days
1407 Lombardy Boulevard 3 1 N/A $369,900 Unknown 8 days
1434 Clinton Avenue 4 2 914 $675,000 $738 8 days
4 Cherokee Drive 4 1 N/A $499,000 Unknown 8 days
2 Robin Lane 2 1 N/A $88,000 Unknown 10 days
974 Manor Lane 3 1 N/A $535,000 Unknown 11 days
173 Ithaca Street 3 3 1,898 $699,999 $368 12 days
49 Lakeside Lane Unit #49 2 2 N/A $699,000 Unknown 12 days
122 Admirals Drive Unit #122 3 3 2,669 $798,000 $298 12 days
1711 Heckscher Avenue 3 2 N/A $499,000 Unknown 12 days
29 2nd Avenue 3 2 N/A $440,000 Unknown 90 days
1236 Hyman Avenue 4 2 1,209 $594,999 $492 13 days
33 Abrew Street 5 2 N/A $449,900 Unknown 14 days
1550 Gardiner Drive 3 2 1,300 $359,990 $276 13 days
1396 Forks Road 2 1 720 $390,000 $541 21 days
35 Princeton Street 3 2 1,700 $529,000 $311 20 days
42 Chapman Place 6 3 N/A $549,000 Unknown 22 days
438 Spur Drive 6 3 N/A $649,000 Unknown 25 days
422 Spur Drive 4 1 N/A $430,000 Unknown 27 days
76 Millay Lane 4 2 N/A $529,999 Unknown 27 days
14 Sylvan Street 4 3 N/A $549,999 Unknown 28 days
12 Belgrave 2 1 N/A $340,000 Unknown 29 days
1410 Windsor Avenue 2 2 N/A $389,000 Unknown 31 days
21 William Street 3 1 N/A $350,000 Unknown 32 days
1690 Pine Grove Boulevard 3 1 N/A $399,999 Unknown 33 days
211 Otis Lane Unit #211 2 2 N/A $645,000 Unknown 34 days
47 Arizona Ave 5 3 2,358 $659,000 $279 31 days
1B Hemlock Drive Unit #143 1 1 N/A $114,900 Unknown 40 days
33 Redington Street 2 2 N/A $370,000 Unknown 41 days
11 Admirals E Drive Unit #11 3 3 2,535 $599,990 $236 41 days
1652 Thompson Drive 3 1 1,106 $350,000 $316 42 days
46 Stewart Street 3 1 N/A $414,999 Unknown 50 days
1832 5th Avenue N/A N/A N/A $599,999 Unknown 53 days
21 Duke Street 3 2 N/A $475,000 Unknown 54 days
1427 Windsor Avenue 2 1 N/A $399,999 Unknown 54 days
2 Redington Street 5 2 N/A $749,000 Unknown 57 days
1785 Stein Drive 8 3 N/A $450,000 Unknown 62 days
1674 Gardiner Drive 3 1 N/A $370,000 Unknown 3 days
1308 Park Avenue 3 1 1,573 $420,000 $267 64 days
1325 Peters Boulevard 6 3 13,504 $675,000 $49 66 days
18 Garner Lane 5 6 6,500 $2,550,000 $392 75 days
146 Awixa Avenue 5 3 N/A $999,000 Unknown 75 days
Average: 3.6 2.2 2,400 $645,417 $328 52 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 94
Viewing 1 - 50 of 94
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
19 Elm 2 1 N/A $45,000 Unknown 0 days
25 Locust Drive 4 1 N/A $349,000 Unknown 14 days
95 Howells Road 2 1 900 $349,000 $387 19 days
37 Connecticut Avenue 4 3 N/A $419,999 Unknown 18 days
36 Millay Lane 3 1 1,966 $400,000 $203 1 day
1338 Ackerson Boulevard 5 3 2,730 $559,000 $204 23 days
4 Krause Street 4 1 N/A $299,316 Unknown 15 days
93 Park Avenue 3 1 N/A $380,000 Unknown 15 days
152 Penataquit Avenue 4 1 1,500 $299,000 $199 6 days
21 Sunny Lane 3 3 N/A $679,000 Unknown 25 days
321 Pine Drive 4 1 1,080 $429,000 $397 25 days
1667 Thompson Drive 2 1 N/A $320,000 Unknown 25 days
1459 Denver Avenue 4 2 1,776 $549,999 $309 5 days
58 Oakridge Drive 5 3 2,434 $649,900 $267 22 days
1019 Merriam Road 3 1 N/A $469,000 Unknown 21 days
134 Clinton Avenue 4 2 1,800 $485,000 $269 31 days
979 Gardiner Drive 4 3 N/A $625,000 Unknown 15 days
23 Burnett Avenue 4 3 N/A $699,000 Unknown 5 days
201 Captains Way Unit #201 3 3 2,762 $925,000 $334 20 days
1532 Pine Acres Boulevard 3 1 1,217 $475,000 $390 2 days
1079 Courtland Drive 5 2 2,064 $549,990 $266 22 days
46 Princess Avenue 6 4 N/A $649,000 Unknown 9 days
178 Missouri Avenue 4 2 N/A $649,999 Unknown 29 days
1840 Heckscher Avenue 6 2 3,069 $579,000 $188 13 days
7 Chicago Court 5 2 N/A $499,000 Unknown 7 days
1378 Pine Drive 2 1 899 $399,000 $443 11 days
1624 Brightshore Boulevard 5 2 N/A $549,999 Unknown 23 days
1119 Nugent Avenue 3 1 1,250 $299,900 $239 58 days
1009 Martinstein Avenue 3 2 2,450 $599,999 $244 7 days
130 Smith Street 3 2 N/A $477,000 Unknown 23 days
163 Boathouse Lane Unit #163 3 3 N/A $625,000 Unknown 13 days
1348 Illinois Avenue 3 1 N/A $449,000 Unknown 6 days
39 19th Avenue 3 1 N/A $319,999 Unknown 20 days
1351 Pine Drive 4 1 1,471 $440,000 $299 35 days
40 Princess Avenue 5 2 N/A $639,990 Unknown 50 days
1449 Baldwin Boulevard 4 2 N/A $499,999 Unknown 5 days
49 Belford Avenue 2 2 N/A $400,000 Unknown 70 days
159 5th Avenue 3 1 N/A $275,000 Unknown 4 days
1733 5th Avenue 3 2 N/A $499,000 Unknown 72 days
1310 Potter Boulevard 4 2 N/A $550,000 Unknown 46 days
308 4th Avenue 6 2 N/A $659,000 Unknown 13 days
16 Pleasant Lane Unit #16 3 3 1,993 $609,000 $305 52 days
19 Pleasant Lane Unit #19 3 3 N/A $599,900 Unknown 74 days
1238 Chicago Avenue 3 3 N/A $489,000 Unknown 19 days
1156 Namdac Avenue 4 4 N/A $790,000 Unknown 38 days
17 Newbrook Lane Unit #17 1 1 N/A $210,000 Unknown 28 days
5 West Drive 3 1 N/A $399,999 Unknown 29 days
1024 Thompson Drive 3 2 N/A $400,000 Unknown 21 days
104 Baltimore Street 3 2 1,950 $529,000 $271 6 days
1584 Thompson Drive 3 1 N/A $434,999 Unknown 70 days
Average: 3.8 2.2 2,160 $527,701 $291 51 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 124
Viewing 1 - 50 of 124
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
1070 Ocean Avenue 3 1 1,158 $364,500 $390,000 $336 50 days 11/28/22
1645 Thompson Drive 4 1 N/A $399,999 $419,000 Unknown 60 days 11/23/22
1350 Peters Boulevard 3 2 N/A $535,000 $552,000 Unknown 5 days 11/21/22
52 5th Avenue 3 2 1,300 $425,000 $450,000 $346 8 days 11/21/22
1456 Lombardy Boulevard 3 1 1,026 $334,900 $334,900 $326 19 days 11/18/22
3 Longshore Street 4 3 N/A $478,000 $500,000 Unknown 22 days 11/18/22
1366 Pine Acres Boulevard 3 2 N/A $489,000 $499,000 Unknown 80 days 11/18/22
102 Penataquit Avenue 3 3 3,000 $879,999 $865,000 $288 44 days 11/17/22
1617 Brentwood Road 3 1 N/A $479,000 $470,000 Unknown 10 days 11/16/22
401 Mystic Way 3 3 N/A $649,000 $639,000 Unknown 69 days 11/16/22
1233 Howells Road 3 3 N/A $499,000 $505,000 Unknown 19 days 11/15/22
1408 3rd Avenue 3 2 N/A $539,000 $535,000 Unknown 10 days 11/15/22
7 Atlantic Street 5 4 N/A $799,999 $650,000 Unknown 80 days 11/15/22
1464 Lombardy Boulevard 6 2 N/A $519,000 $519,000 Unknown 15 days 11/14/22
199 Louise Drive 3 2 2,126 $489,000 $492,500 $231 78 days 11/14/22
59 Jefferson Avenue 4 2 N/A $449,990 $530,000 Unknown 27 days 11/11/22
157 Baywoods Lane Unit #157 3 3 1,950 $670,000 $685,000 $351 10 days 11/10/22
10 Plume Court 4 2 N/A $479,000 $500,000 Unknown 25 days 11/10/22
10 Wenman Avenue 3 2 1,420 $519,000 $515,000 $362 19 days 11/10/22
10 Willowbrook Avenue N/A N/A N/A $599,000 $555,000 Unknown 61 days 11/10/22
10 Willowbrook Avenue 4 3 N/A $599,000 $555,000 Unknown 62 days 11/10/22
57 Girard Avenue 5 2 2,800 $599,999 $550,000 $196 89 days 11/10/22
368 Brook Avenue 3 2 N/A $499,000 $525,000 Unknown 16 days 11/9/22
1461 Richland Boulevard 3 2 N/A $499,900 $480,000 Unknown 66 days 11/9/22
161 Boathouse Lane Unit #161 2 2 N/A $585,000 $575,000 Unknown 78 days 11/8/22
1083 Manor Lane 5 2 1,600 $550,000 $550,000 $343 29 days 11/7/22
3 Aspen Ave 1 1 900 $49,000 $30,000 $33 151 days 11/5/22
41 Torrey Pine Lane Unit #41 2 4 2,054 $563,000 $563,000 $274 32 days 11/4/22
125 Bayway Avenue 2 1 N/A $529,990 $545,000 Unknown 54 days 11/4/22
109 Huron Drive 3 2 1,600 $499,000 $515,000 $321 9 days 11/4/22
16 Joseph Street 3 2 N/A $479,000 $500,000 Unknown 23 days 11/2/22
1599 Stein Drive 5 3 N/A $599,000 $620,000 Unknown 7 days 11/2/22
1253 Hyman Avenue 3 2 1,410 $459,000 $485,000 $343 22 days 11/2/22
897 Gardiner Drive 5 4 N/A $999,900 $999,900 Unknown 20 days 11/2/22
60 Maple Avenue 5 5 N/A $1,299,999 $1,230,000 Unknown 80 days 11/2/22
21 2nd Avenue 4 2 N/A $438,000 $380,000 Unknown 21 days 11/1/22
1350 Windsor Avenue 4 3 N/A $524,999 $540,000 Unknown 4 days 10/31/22
1559 Brightshore Boulevard 3 1 N/A $449,990 $475,000 Unknown 17 days 10/31/22
40 Arizona Avenue 6 2 1,786 $549,000 $585,000 $327 13 days 10/28/22
12 Mystic Circle Unit #12 2 2 N/A $499,000 $600,000 Unknown 12 days 10/27/22
1035 Thompson Drive 4 2 1,680 $624,900 $599,000 $356 112 days 10/26/22
1129 Joselson Avenue 3 2 N/A $449,999 $486,000 Unknown 14 days 10/26/22
1104 Martinstein Avenue 4 2 1,854 $489,999 $505,000 $272 33 days 10/26/22
6 Henry Place 3 1 N/A $399,999 $450,000 Unknown 41 days 10/26/22
41 Chenango Drive 3 1 1,044 $369,000 $375,000 $359 20 days 10/25/22
52 Seafield Lane 3 2 N/A $699,000 $655,000 Unknown 30 days 10/24/22
1542 Baldwin Boulevard 4 2 N/A $525,000 $520,000 Unknown 19 days 10/24/22
1399 Chicago Avenue 5 3 N/A $599,999 $605,000 Unknown 11 days 10/21/22
18 Lakeland Street 4 1 N/A $499,999 $505,000 Unknown 28 days 10/21/22
907 Thompson Drive 4 3 N/A $949,000 $925,000 Unknown 2 days 10/20/22
Average: 3.5 2.2 2,101 $541,980 $552,567 $5,620 31 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 240
Viewing 1 - 50 of 240

Information Copyright 2016, Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc. All Rights Reserved. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc.