Sign up to stay up to date on the Bay Shore Home Values!

or Create your own market report
Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
34 2nd Avenue 5 2 2,130 $599,000 $281 0 days
177 Massachusetts Avenue 3 1 10,890 $525,000 $48 0 days
1411 Manatuck Boulevard 4 2 1,714 $569,990 $332 2 days
90 Redmond Avenue 3 3 N/A $479,999 Unknown 40 days
1456 Manatuck Boulevard 3 1 N/A $419,999 Unknown 2 days
1409 Brooklyn Boulevard 4 2 N/A $459,000 Unknown 0 days
66 Center Avenue 3 2 1,316 $449,999 $341 4 days
11 Inlet View 4 2 2,324 $799,999 $344 5 days
242 Helm Lane Unit #242 3 2 2,138 $699,000 $326 5 days
74 Princess Avenue 3 1 N/A $475,000 Unknown 5 days
41 Chenango Drive 3 1 1,044 $369,000 $353 8 days
104 Autumn Court 3 3 1,507 $353,000 $234 8 days
65 Pine Air Drive N/A N/A N/A $75,000 Unknown 11 days
6 Pleasant Lane Unit #6 3 3 1,434 $649,000 $452 13 days
1586 Thompson Drive 4 2 N/A $390,000 Unknown 13 days
21 2nd Avenue 5 2 N/A $438,000 Unknown 13 days
1350 Windsor Avenue 4 3 N/A $524,999 Unknown 4 days
6 Lakemont Street 4 2 2,248 $649,999 $289 7 days
17 Garner Lane 5 7 5,818 $1,999,999 $343 14 days
136 Penataquit Avenue 3 2 1,737 $429,000 $246 15 days
1382 Thompson Drive 4 3 2,600 $550,000 $211 14 days
1729 5th Avenue 2 1 N/A $399,000 Unknown 15 days
51 Oakdale Street 4 2 2,086 $479,990 $230 16 days
2 Grace Court 3 3 N/A $925,000 Unknown 7 days
1429 Ackerson Boulevard 3 1 N/A $419,999 Unknown 4 days
1175 Nugent Avenue 3 2 N/A $579,000 Unknown 18 days
1070 Ocean Avenue 3 1 1,158 $364,500 $314 20 days
16 Lawrence Lane 4 4 3,457 $1,100,000 $318 19 days
22 Lakeside Lane Unit #22 2 3 2,178 $599,000 $275 20 days
3 W Bay Shore Road N/A N/A N/A $170,000 Unknown 21 days
401 Mystic Way 3 3 N/A $695,000 Unknown 22 days
2 Poplar Place 3 2 1,714 $499,999 $291 21 days
1670 3rd Avenue 9 4 3,484 $890,500 $255 19 days
241 Helm Lane Unit #241 3 2 2,087 $789,000 $378 25 days
74 Bardolier Lane 3 2 1,417 $549,990 $388 26 days
1788 Heckscher Avenue 6 2 N/A $599,999 Unknown 27 days
134 Baywoods Lane Unit #134 3 2 2,572 $620,134 $241 27 days
29 1st Avenue 5 2 1,600 $379,000 $236 28 days
201 Bay Shore Road 5 4 N/A $799,000 Unknown 24 days
90 Bay Shore Road 4 3 1,657 $549,990 $331 25 days
18 Lakeland Street 4 1 N/A $499,999 Unknown 28 days
33 Homan Avenue 4 2 1,458 $524,990 $360 28 days
7 Atlantic Street 5 4 N/A $799,999 Unknown 30 days
1023 Udall Road 3 1 N/A $454,000 Unknown 6 days
21 2nd Avenue N/A N/A N/A $438,000 Unknown 33 days
1579 5th Avenue N/A N/A N/A $299,999 Unknown 33 days
1393 Ackerson Boulevard 5 2 2,188 $669,000 $305 34 days
310 Delaware Avenue 4 3 2,000 $519,000 $259 26 days
117 5th Avenue N/A N/A N/A $289,999 Unknown 34 days
110 Queen Street 4 2 1,518 $499,888 $329 34 days
Average: 3.6 2.3 2,404 $739,775 $294 45 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 129
Viewing 1 - 50 of 129
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
39 Ridgeway Boulevard 2 1 1,250 $474,999 $379 5 days
40 Arizona Avenue 6 2 1,786 $549,000 $307 20 days
3 Longshore Street 4 3 N/A $478,000 Unknown 22 days
136 Mariner Lane Unit #136 3 3 2,669 $795,000 $297 25 days
1559 Brightshore Boulevard 3 1 N/A $449,990 Unknown 17 days
29 Community Road 5 5 2,488 $649,000 $260 17 days
1436 Windsor Avenue 3 2 N/A $499,000 Unknown 9 days
57 Johnson Lane 3 2 1,400 $499,000 $356 30 days
52 Seafield Lane 3 2 N/A $699,000 Unknown 30 days
46 Princess Avenue 6 4 1,400 $649,500 $463 29 days
1341 Lombardy Boulevard 3 1 1,170 $335,000 $286 16 days
1437 Ackerson Boulevard 4 3 N/A $530,000 Unknown 34 days
242 Spur S Drive 3 1 N/A $499,999 Unknown 8 days
1542 Baldwin Boulevard 4 2 N/A $525,000 Unknown 19 days
1161 Joselson Avenue 3 1 1,310 $439,900 $335 35 days
1397 3rd Avenue 6 2 N/A $599,000 Unknown 0 days
15 Chimney Lane 3 2 N/A $455,000 Unknown 47 days
19 Edwin Street 4 2 N/A $449,000 Unknown 10 days
1325 Manor Lane 3 2 N/A $500,000 Unknown 33 days
51 Minnesota Avenue 4 2 N/A $449,999 Unknown 16 days
1252 Boston Avenue 3 1 N/A $499,999 Unknown 5 days
284 Helm Lane Unit #284 2 2 2,198 $769,000 $349 7 days
20 Locust Drive 3 2 N/A $469,000 Unknown 11 days
17 Seminole Drive 3 2 738 $389,000 $527 36 days
1658 Gardiner Drive 3 2 N/A $499,999 Unknown 15 days
1083 Manor Lane 5 2 1,600 $550,000 $343 29 days
940 Manor Lane 4 3 2,900 $549,900 $189 9 days
43 Ellen Street 3 1 N/A $339,000 Unknown 55 days
1104 Martinstein Avenue 4 2 1,854 $489,999 $264 33 days
1410 Windsor Avenue 2 2 N/A $399,999 Unknown 11 days
104 Chenango Drive 5 2 1,984 $589,900 $297 26 days
42 Frederick Avenue 5 3 1,845 $575,000 $311 61 days
164 Ithaca Street 3 2 1,500 $499,900 $333 5 days
10 Villa Prm Unit #10 3 3 2,175 $629,999 $289 62 days
227 Gunther Avenue 4 2 1,185 $520,000 $438 19 days
418 Asharoken Boulevard 2 1 750 $399,999 $533 9 days
188 Prospect 5 3 N/A $539,900 Unknown 15 days
1645 Thompson Drive 4 1 N/A $399,999 Unknown 60 days
6 Villa Promenade 3 3 2,200 $659,999 $299 25 days
1665 Elsie Lane 4 2 1,824 $550,000 $301 68 days
8 Captains Walk Unit #8 3 3 3,836 $1,395,000 $363 29 days
16 Burnett Avenue 3 2 1,736 $479,000 $275 32 days
118 Greenwood Road 5 2 N/A $599,000 Unknown 45 days
1443 Pine Drive 4 2 N/A $500,000 Unknown 22 days
60 Brook Avenue 5 2 N/A $499,999 Unknown 7 days
19 Lakemont St 5 3 N/A $539,000 Unknown 18 days
11 Candlewood Road 4 1 720 $459,000 $637 26 days
11 Girard Avenue 3 3 N/A $810,000 Unknown 28 days
1104 Namdac Avenue 3 2 N/A $429,999 Unknown 7 days
1354 Peters Boulevard 3 2 N/A $459,000 Unknown 23 days
Average: 3.6 2.3 2,120 $551,536 $327 43 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 120
Viewing 1 - 50 of 120
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
717 Montauk 6 4 7,964 $779,900 $785,100 $98 27 days 8/10/22
1449 Ackerson Boulevard 3 2 N/A $449,999 $500,000 Unknown 15 days 8/10/22
124 3rd Avenue 4 2 N/A $480,000 $500,000 Unknown 59 days 8/9/22
1429 Peters Boulevard 4 2 1,904 $499,000 $530,000 $278 19 days 8/8/22
1666 Elsie Lane 4 2 1,536 $479,000 $560,000 $364 5 days 8/8/22
1544 Heckscher Avenue 2 1 N/A $419,999 $441,000 Unknown 20 days 8/8/22
1388 Illinois Avenue 2 1 N/A $359,900 $360,000 Unknown 23 days 8/5/22
26 Sugar Pine Lane Unit #26 2 3 2,056 $550,000 $571,500 $277 3 days 8/5/22
906 Gardiner Drive 5 5 3,850 $869,000 $875,000 $227 17 days 8/3/22
109 Oakdale Street 4 3 N/A $615,000 $600,000 Unknown 14 days 8/3/22
263 4th Avenue 2 2 N/A $399,000 $419,000 Unknown 10 days 8/2/22
2 Gateway Drive 3 2 1,582 $599,990 $550,000 $347 23 days 8/2/22
9 Brook Avenue 3 1 850 $399,900 $420,000 $494 154 days 8/2/22
44 Smith Avenue Unit #NA 3 2 N/A $399,000 $425,000 Unknown 29 days 8/1/22
114 1st Avenue 3 1 1,000 $325,000 $370,000 $370 25 days 8/1/22
43 Indiana Avenue 3 2 N/A $389,000 $370,000 Unknown 5 days 8/1/22
118 N Clinton Avenue 3 3 2,065 $450,000 $500,000 $242 3 days 7/29/22
1009 Thompson Drive 4 3 N/A $640,000 $630,000 Unknown 25 days 7/29/22
1 Abrew Street 5 2 2,328 $535,000 $565,000 $242 26 days 7/29/22
9 Idaho Avenue 3 1 N/A $399,000 $405,000 Unknown 6 days 7/28/22
219 Brentwood Street 4 2 N/A $449,000 $502,000 Unknown 18 days 7/28/22
186 Missouri Avenue 7 4 N/A $719,000 $690,000 Unknown 14 days 7/28/22
949 Gardiner Drive 4 3 2,000 $474,900 $450,000 $225 17 days 7/27/22
1066 Carll Drive 4 4 N/A $575,000 $625,000 Unknown 18 days 7/27/22
179 5th Avenue 5 3 N/A $519,000 $530,000 Unknown 36 days 7/26/22
507 Pine Drive 6 4 2,400 $579,900 $550,000 $229 121 days 7/26/22
116 Baltimore Street 4 2 N/A $540,000 $530,000 Unknown 18 days 7/25/22
20 Montauk Drive 3 2 1,200 $519,900 $628,000 $523 6 days 7/25/22
1415 Lombardy Boulevard 3 1 1,200 $398,999 $440,000 $366 18 days 7/25/22
23 Claremont Avenue 3 1 N/A $437,900 $460,000 Unknown 119 days 7/25/22
1600 Baldwin Boulevard 5 2 2,100 $519,900 $515,000 $245 11 days 7/22/22
291 4th Avenue 3 2 N/A $499,999 $490,000 Unknown 23 days 7/22/22
35 West Lane 5 4 4,000 $1,149,000 $1,035,000 $258 116 days 7/22/22
976 Gardiner Drive 3 2 N/A $599,000 $615,000 Unknown 28 days 7/21/22
1469 Lincoln Boulevard 3 2 N/A $479,000 $530,000 Unknown 4 days 7/21/22
17 Longshore Street 3 1 N/A $449,990 $449,990 Unknown 5 days 7/21/22
19 Connecticut Avenue 4 2 N/A $289,000 $305,000 Unknown 19 days 7/21/22
1322 Pine Acres Boulevard 4 2 1,650 $459,500 $490,000 $296 17 days 7/20/22
5 Fire Rd Drive 5 3 N/A $600,000 $645,000 Unknown 57 days 7/20/22
1138 Hyman Avenue 3 2 N/A $549,000 $629,000 Unknown 7 days 7/18/22
6 Runyon Street 5 3 2,148 $675,000 $685,000 $318 7 days 7/18/22
23 Sunset Road 4 3 N/A $699,000 $799,000 Unknown 1 day 7/15/22
1066 Bay Shore Avenue 4 1 N/A $389,999 $448,000 Unknown 32 days 7/15/22
274 Helm Lane Unit #274 3 2 N/A $735,000 $730,000 Unknown 37 days 7/15/22
980 Manor Lane 4 2 2,400 $699,000 $715,000 $297 20 days 7/15/22
1724 Gardiner Drive 5 2 N/A $540,000 $540,000 Unknown 5 days 7/14/22
1690 Westwood Boulevard 3 1 N/A $375,000 $448,000 Unknown 26 days 7/14/22
1387 Pine Acres Boulevard 4 2 N/A $599,000 $576,000 Unknown 19 days 7/13/22
412 Asharoken Boulevard 3 1 N/A $449,900 $480,000 Unknown 20 days 7/13/22
353 Pennsylvania Avenue 4 2 N/A $625,000 $615,000 Unknown 6 days 7/12/22
Average: 3.6 2.2 2,657 $528,639 $537,024 $6,419 35 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 214
Viewing 1 - 50 of 214

Information Copyright 2016, Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc. All Rights Reserved. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc.